This article makes explicit some of the greatest gifts these learning gardens have to offer. The first that really resonated was its ability to act as a community space. The universal appeal of these learning garden brings together many ways of life, cultivating rich experiences teeming with diversity. During my adult life in Vancouver, I’ve noticed that there are very few community spaces that meaningfully serve Vancouver’s multi-cultural communities. Even existing community gardens in many parts of the city are not generally thought of as gathering places (this is a generalization - the Strathcona community garden, for example, is incredible). Applying some of the philosophies of learning gardens to community gardens might help transform them into something attractive to a broader community.
I was also moved by how the article discussed embracing the
garden as a co-teacher. By minimizing human-made infrastructure, the gardens
can help us develop a real, authentic relationship with the natural world. I
can affirm the absence of this experience in typical STEM education. This is
tragic given that these are often the people who shape our physical world. We
would be wise to ensure that these students have ample opportunities to develop
an intimate relationship with the world they are so eager to change.
In the context of Secondary math, I can most easily envision
group work taking place in a garden setting. I envision groups of 3-4, standing
up, working through a sheet of problems on a portable whiteboard. Experience
this semester gives me confidence this can happen in a learning garden.
Furthermore, I speculate that students in tune with the spirits will find mathematical
guidance in extremely novel ways.
The most notable difficulties I foresee relate to
distractions and fatigue. In particular if it is a hot day, working in an outdoor
space requires a lot of energy that might otherwise be used for math.
Additionally, distractions within the garden (insects, wind, physical
discomfort) might easily pull students away from the task at hand.
Pro Grades
ReplyDelete- Clear expectations that grades set (what are the expectations)
- How can students allocate their time appropriately
- no mystery in advance of giving feedback
- Teachers can keep themselves accountable
- Grades scale well
- Its not grades the problem, but society’s relationship with grades
- Gr
How can we leverage grades to promote community & classroom culture
What is distinction between grades & feedback
How can we encourage self-reflection (some students might be resistant)
Do grades or feedback promote student autonomy
Anti grades
- Discourages authentic learning experience (taking risks, curiosity)
- Devaluing of low performers and toxic environment it creates
- Exaggerates existing SES conditions
- Promotes rote learning & instrumental
- Feedback promotes growth, grades can’t
- Grades encourage cheating